Skip to Content

Custom Knives: Should I Buy One? (Costs, Investment & More)

As an Amazon Associate, we earn from qualifying purchases with no additional costs for you.

Increased access to affordable tools and machinery has resulted in many custom knifemakers producing handmade knives for sale. Are these knives worth the cost, and should a custom knife be something you should consider buying?

Custom knives are a worthwhile buy for a knife enthusiast or anyone in need of a superior-quality knife. Custom knives are built by hand by knifemakers who take time and care in the design and creation of the knife. Top-quality materials are used to make a durable, practical work of art!

There are good and bad custom knives, making it important to thoroughly research the knifemaker and customer reviews before committing to buying one of their custom knives. While you may get a quality knife when buying a custom knife, there is also the possibility that you will get a sub-standard knife or pay more than you should for the knife.

If you are interested in sharpening your custom-made knives by yourself, we recommend buying a whetstone set. The best option is to buy Shapton Kuromaku Whetstone Set (Amazon link) with 320-grit fixing stone, 1000-grit sharpening stone, and 5000-grit polishing stone. The alternative (cheaper) option is the Sharp Pebble Set (Amazon link) with 400, 1000, and 6000 grits.

Are Custom Knives Worth the Money?
Are Custom Knives Worth the Money?

What Is A Custom Knife?

A custom knife is typically a knife that has been made by a private knifemaker rather than a recognized brand.

Custom knife makers can be hobbyists who make custom knives in their spare time or knifemakers who create custom knives for a living.

Either way, the knifemaking operation is usually small, and the processes are manual rather than automated. This means the knives are not mass-produced, but each knife is made individually by hand, making it unique.

Due to much of the knifemaking process for custom knives being by hand, there is greater attention to detail in each knife’s design, creation, and finish.

This attention to detail generally creates a superior product to factory-made knives. This reputation of custom-made knives has seen their popularity grow among knife enthusiasts and outdoors people such as survivalists, campers, and hikers.

How Much Does a Custom Knife Cost?

How Much Does a Custom Knife Cost?
How Much Does a Custom Knife Cost?

Considering the time and effort a knifemaker puts into creating custom knives, you can expect to pay a higher price for custom knives than for mass-produced knives.

The selection of materials used in making a custom knife is also usually of a higher standard, such as superior quality steel and handle materials.

The attention to detail in the processes of creating the knife usually results in a stronger, more robust, and more durable knife.

How much can you expect to pay for a custom knife in comparison to an off-the-shelf factory knife? The costs will vary from knifemaker to knifemaker and from knife to knife.

The only thing you can be sure of is that you will pay more for a custom knife than you will for a factory knife.

Generally, you can expect to pay anywhere from $400 to $1000 for a custom knife, depending on the steel and other materials that went into the build and the amount of fine detail in the knife design.

A custom knife is not only a working tool but a work of art that will likely become a family heirloom that can be passed down from generation to generation.

TIP: There are so many knife steels available that it becomes confusing to choose which is the best steel for your dream custom-made knife. Check out the complete list with an explanation in the article below:
Full List: Best Knife Steels For Different Knives (+ Why)

Are Custom Knives Worth the Money?

Are Custom Knives Worth the Money?
Are Custom Knives Worth the Money?

When people see the price of a custom knife, the first reaction is usually one of shock, and they wonder how a knifemaker can justify the cost.

When you take a closer look at a custom knife and appreciate the time, effort, and quality materials that went into the building of the knife, you begin to understand the price tag.

Most custom knife makers select premium quality steel, handle materials, pins, and other materials for their knives. The craftsmanship that goes into creating the knife is exceptional because the knifemaker realizes that each knife represents their name and reputation.

The labor and attention to detail that is put into crafting custom knives make these works a cut above the rest in terms of quality of finish, durability, and performance.

Most people don’t expect a $40 mass-produced factory knife to last a lifetime, but you can certainly expect this kind of longevity from a custom knife.

Custom knives are certainly worth the money, and you will receive a quality knife for the price you pay

Many custom knifemakers will make a knife that is specifically crafted for you, with a unique design, and made for your specific hand size if you send in your hand measurements.

Consequently, a custom knife usually has better balance and feel in the hand than a mass-produced generic factory knife.

TIP: Japanese kitchen knives are considered to be the ultimate kitchen tools and offer a level of prestige in the kitchen. Check out the explanation of usage for all types of Japanese knives in the article below:
All Japanese Knife Types Explained (Purpose, Usage & More)

Are Custom Knives A Good Investment?

Should I Buy a Custom Knife?
Should I Buy a Custom Knife?

Most buyers purchase a knife as a tool and will use it for their intended purpose. However, some custom knives are beautiful works of art and are intended to be display pieces rather than working tools.

Some knifemakers in this genre have a following of passionate collectors, and the knives made by these creators fetch a high price.

Even some makers of working custom knives generate a following due to their knives’ quality. As with any market supply and demand situation, if the demand outstrips the supply, the product becomes sought-after and demands a higher price.

There is value in these knives, but the knife will only retain its investment value if there is a continued demand for knives by the particular maker.

A custom knife is a good investment from the aspect that you will have a quality product that can last a lifetime, but there are better ways of investing your money if you are seeking to make a profit on your investments.

TIP: Damascus steel does not only look appealing, but it is often used for making custom-made knives. Check out how to care for Damascus steel knives in the article below:
PRO Tips: Taking Care & Cleaning Of Damascus Steel Knives

Should I Buy a Custom Knife?

Should I Buy a Custom Knife?
Should I Buy a Custom Knife?

A knife is a very personal item, so if you can find a knife that matches your ideal requirements in a knife, then you will have a useful, well-made tool.

Generally, custom knives fit these criteria more frequently than factory knives because of the additional care invested in the knife’s design and creation and the quality of the materials used.

In most cases, I recommend a custom knife as a good purchase and one where you will not have a buyer’s regret. However, before buying a custom knife, you should research the knifemaker and any reviews from previous customers who own knives from the maker.

In any market where you have items that fetch a higher price, you will find unscrupulous suppliers that try to take advantage of buyers.

A custom knife is a worthwhile purchase, but do your homework on the maker to ensure you will receive the quality knife you expect.

TIP: Are you looking to buy a new whetstone? Check out our recommendations (we personally use the first three ones):

Our PRO choice whetstones combo (Amazon links):

Our budget choice (Amazon link): Sharp Pebble Extra Large Sharpening Stone Set

Your Ultimate Guide to Choosing the Perfect Custom Knife

Your Ultimate Guide to Choosing the Perfect Custom Knife
Your Ultimate Guide to Choosing the Perfect Custom Knife

When selecting a custom knife, the choices can be as varied and unique as the individuals who wield them. Whether you’re a culinary enthusiast, an outdoor adventurer, or a collector of fine blades, understanding the nuances of custom knives is crucial to making the right choice. 

Here’s a guide to help you navigate the world of custom knives and select one that perfectly suits your needs and preferences.

Understanding Blade Material

The heart of any knife is its blade and the material it’s made from plays a pivotal role in its performance. Here are some common materials used in custom knives:

Stainless Steel: Known for its rust resistance and ease of maintenance. It is ideal for kitchen knives or humid environments.

Carbon Steel: Praised for its edge retention and sharpness, but requires more maintenance to prevent rust.

Damascus Steel: Renowned for its distinctive patterns, combining the benefits of different steels. It’s a popular choice for collectors and aesthetic enthusiasts.

Handle Design and Material

The handle is not just about aesthetics; it’s about comfort and functionality. Consider these factors:

Material: Options range from traditional woods to modern composites and even metals. Each material offers a different balance of weight, grip, and feel.

Ergonomics: The handle should fit comfortably in your hand. Consider the shape and size that will best suit your grip and intended use.

Knife Size and Shape

The size and shape of the knife should align with its intended purpose:

Culinary Knives: Chef’s knives, paring knives, and bread knives each have specific shapes and sizes suited to kitchen tasks.

Outdoor Knives: Hunting, camping, and survival knives have more robust designs and are suitable for cutting, carving, and other rugged uses.

Collectible Knives: Often more about design and craftsmanship, these can vary widely in size and shape.

Intended Use

Consider what you’ll primarily use the knife for:

Culinary: Look for balance, sharpness, and a comfortable handle.

Outdoor Activities: Durability, blade strength, and versatility are key.

Collecting: Focus on craftsmanship, design, and material quality.

Identifying Quality Craftsmanship

A well-crafted knife is the sum of its parts. Pay attention to:

Balance: A well-balanced knife feels solid and comfortable in the hand.

Joints and Seams: These should be smooth and well-aligned, indicating attention to detail.

Blade Edge: A uniformly sharp and well-ground edge speaks to the maker’s skill.

Customization Options

One of the joys of a custom knife is the ability to personalize it. Consider:

Engravings: Personalize your knife with a name, initials, or a special design.

Custom Fit: Some makers offer knives tailored to your hand size or grip style.

Choosing a custom knife is a personal journey. It’s about finding that perfect balance of form, function, and aesthetic that resonates with you. 

Take your time to explore the options, communicate with the craftsman, and you’ll find a knife that’s not just a tool but a treasure.


Custom knives are a thing of beauty to most knife enthusiasts! These knives have elegant, crisp lines, creative designs, superior balance and comfort, and the assurance of quality materials.

Not only are custom knives a pleasure to behold, but they also provide a better user experience when the knife is used. If you can afford a custom knife, it is certainly a treat you will enjoy for a long time!

TIP: Understanding whetstone grit levels can be a little confusing at first, but it is really important, especially when you sharpen your expensive custom-made knives. Find out more in the article below:
Complete GUIDE About Whetstone Grit: Levels & What To Buy